It’s only makes sense that
ABC would try to find a series to fill the void that the end of Desperate Housewives is going create in
its Sunday night schedule. That show was a ratings juggernaut for its first
couple years, maintained a healthy audience over the next few, but has at this
point pretty much fallen out of the Top 20. Given that the series lost a great
deal of its initial edge and creative steam, that should come as no surprise,
but what if the net could concoct something as juicy and fun to watch as Housewives was back in its heyday?
GCB, which
sounds like a chain of health food stores, is an acronym for Good Christian Bitches, the title of the
bestselling book by Kim Gatlin, upon which the series is based, and the sooner
we all forget the sanitized placeholder title Good Christian Belles, which ABC had some time ago considered
using, the better. Is it a terrible move to have reduced the profane into
something squeaky clean and network TV safe? Hasn’t ABC simply done what fans
gabbing on internet message boards will do within hours of the show’s premiere,
anyway?
After her Ponzi-scheming
husband is killed in a fiery crash (blowjob interruptus, of course), Amanda
Vaughn (Leslie Bibb) must move back to Dallas with her two teenage children,
and in with her bible-thumping socialite mother, Gigi (Annie Potts, playing yet
another version of the same woman she’s been exploring for years). Gigi still
lives in the same community she raised Amanda in, and her neighbors are the
same girls her daughter tormented in high school 20 years ago. Though Amanda
has changed, ladies like Carlene Cockburn (Kristin Chenoweth) and Cricket Caruth-Reilly
(Miriam Shor) hold some serious grudges against her, and the new life she’s
attempting to carve for herself and her children will be anything but a hayride.
The overt subtext of the
series involves heaping loads of hypocrisy, frequently of the religious kind.
While the “bitches” attend church every Sunday, their actions are all too often
awfully un-Christian. Do unto others takes a backseat to doo-doo onto others,
and Carlene is the clear ringleader. The characters’ antics are so over the top
it seems unlikely that anyone could take the goings-on too seriously, but then
the writers don’t seem to have taken into account (or perhaps they simply don’t
care) how sensitive half of the country might be to the show’s repeated
condemnation of the double standards of church-going folk.
Part of the key to the
success of Housewives was in its
bleached approach; the only thing offensive about that show was that it wasn’t
even remotely offensive. It was a series that everyone could like. That isn’t the case with GCB, which potentially satirizes a rather large and influential
portion of the country. “Potentially” because you never know where viewers will
draw the line between seeing themselves and insisting “that’s nothing like me.”
It’s anyone’s guess how the religious right is going to react to the show, but
I’ll venture out on a limb and say it’s not something they’re going to embrace.
Yet the series is hell-bent
on being liked, and as long as you don’t live in Highland
Park , the affluent Dallas
suburb GCB is lampooning, maybe it
won’t be so offensive after all. Tall, tan, and athletic blonde Bibb is an
ideal lead for GCB, looking identical
to so many women I’ve known throughout the nearly 25 years I’ve lived in Texas . Though the
supporting players often come off cartoonish, Amanda is grounded in a reality,
and she’s such a thoroughly affable lead, it’s difficult to even imagine her as
the high school bitch everyone else knows her as. When roadblocks are put in
the way of her career, she sees no shame in getting a job at a fictionalized
version of Hooters, despite the fact the Gigi is well enough off to take care
of the entire family. When a mystery donor sends her a truckload full of
expensive, designer clothing, she sends it all back.
Chenoweth chews every bit of
scenery she can get her teeth on, and even her infamous vocals play a sizable
role, as she’s a prominent member of the church choir. Carlene commits some
pretty loathsome acts, yet given that she was, essentially, bullied by Amanda
in high school, you have to sympathize with her on a certain level. Indeed,
this is a series about what happens when the bullied strike back, only we’re
supposed to side with the bully, which is quite the daring angle to take in
this political climate.
On the flip side there’s
Jennifer Aspen’s Sharon Peacham, the former high school beauty, now overweight
and insecure, and a true grotesque. She’s severely underwritten, and the butt
of one too many of the same kind of jokes over the course of the first two episodes.
Shor’s Cricket doesn’t fare much better in the pilot, but the second episode
reveals something decidedly more complex about her, and she just may be the
character to watch over the long haul (and as an unrecognized treasure, Shor
certainly deserves it). Rounding out the main cast is Marisol Nichols as
Heather Cruz, a woman caught between Amanda and Carlene. GCB doesn’t yet know exactly what it wants to do with her
character, which isn’t necessarily a bad thing at this early stage of the game.
However, by the end of this mid-season run, we really need to see where all of
these people are coming from and have a vague idea of where they might be going.
GCB is the
kind of TV programming that snobs like me go into wanting to dislike, and yet cannot
because the show, by prime time network standards, is taking some major risks,
and also because, well, it’s just so damn much fun, much of which is due to
sharp dialogue such as “Why would anyone leave Texas
for southern California ?
I mean, we’ve got the same weather without the liberals.” The show is far from
perfect, and maybe it never will be, because of what it is, where it is, and
when it plays, but it gets far more right than wrong, which quite frankly,
isn’t something I’d have expected from an ABC Sunday night series at this stage
of the scheduling and producing game.